How does monitoring the performance of a Living Building help evaluate design, building response to climate, and occupant behavior?

 

PROJECT INFORMATION

Submitted by:  

Firm Name: University of Washington Integrated Design Lab

ASHRAE Climate Zone: 4C

Building/Space Type:

  • Office

Who performed the simulation analysis?  

  • Architect - Intern

  • University

What tools were used for the simulation analysis? 

  • Rhino - DIVA

What phase of the project was analysis conducted?  

  • Post Occupancy

What are the primary inputs of the analysis?  Since 2013 the Bullitt Center, a net-positive Living Building Certified commercial office building, has been continuously monitored in order to collect a wide range of data points by the University of Washington Integrated Design Lab. This includes data collected from a variety of sensors in order to understand energy use (by floor, end-use), energy generation, climate/weather data, and automated window operation.

What are the primary outputs of the analysis?  This project produced a wide range of outputs that were used to understand the building, evaluate the success of design strategies, and grasp/make changes to occupant behavior. Outputs were originally used to calibrate monitored data by eliminating a discrepancy between sub-meters and total building energy use. The outputs of this project are energy use (by floor, end-use), energy generation, climate/weather, and automated window operation.

PROCESS

List the investigations questions that drove your analysis process.

How does a Living Building Certified project perform over time? What is the impact of occupant behavior on building performance? What are some best practices for monitoring a building? How do energy end uses change by month, floor, and tenant? What portion of the total building EUI is composed of lighting, plug, plumbing, HVAC, IT, and elevator loads? How does plug load usage change throughout the day and by floor? How does the number of people and computers per floor correlate to kWh per person? How does lighting and plug loads break down per floor? How does outside air temperature correlate with hourly energy use? How does automated window operation change by temperature/by month?

How was simulation integrated into the overall design process?

simulation_integrated

How did you set up the simulation analysis and workflow?

The Bullitt Center is constantly monitored through an array of sensors and weather stations. This in essence provides a live simulation of the buildings energy use (by floor, end use), energy collection, climate, and automated window operation. This data was analyzed using Tableau, which in turn was used to begin creating graphics. These data visualizations were then adjusted and enhanced using Adobe Creative Suite and Rhinoceros software. In certain situations, Microsoft Excel was also used to generate simple graphs that were then adjusted in illustrator.

How did you visualize the results to the design team? What was successful about the graphics that you used to communicate the data?

The results of the data analysis were visualized using a combination of Tableau, Microsoft Excel, Adobe Creative Suite, and Rhinoceros. These were then combined into a series of posters that represent the main element of this submission. The posters provide information on a wide range of data collection, combine useful information, and use a series of easy-to-read visualizations. The graphics were successful because of the visual clarity, connection between images, usage of icons/color, and simplification of expression. In the end, conclusions pertaining to the data are easily made because of the clarity of the data visualizations.

Most importantly, what did you learn from the investigation?  How did simulation and its outputs influence the design of the project?

This project is an analysis of post-occupancy data that used visualizations in order to understand the energy performance of a unique building. This is the tail end of a process that began with simulation to inform design decisions in order to achieve a set of rigorous performance goals and the graphics in the submission explore how the building is actually performing. A next step would be to explore how this data and graphics can inform the assumptions of future simulations.